1. Look at the instrument's chlorine concentration range and sample pH range to make your initial decision.
| Specification |
CL17 |
CLF10 sc / CLT10 sc |
| Chlorine Concentration Range |
0-5 mg/L |
0-10 mg/L |
| Sample pH range (w/o buffering) |
Unlimited |
pH 4-9 |
2. Next, consider each technology's key differentiators to determine which technology is preferred for your application.
| Factor |
CL17 |
CLF10 sc / CLT10 sc |
| Impact on readings due to sample pH, chlorine concentration, temp, flow and/or pressure changes |
No impact on readings |
Readings may be impacted, Adjustment to calibration may be needed |
| Calibration |
Calibration not needed |
Yes. Frequency based upon the application |
| Routine Maintenance |
Tubing replacement needed every 6 months |
Membrane and electrolyte replacement every 3-6 months |
| Reagents |
Routine reagent replacement needed every 30 days |
None needed |
| Reagents in Discharge |
Yes |
No |
| Multi-parameter |
Single parameter |
Optional pH and Temperature |
3. Finally, consider the other specifications and the keys to application success to make sure that your preferred instrument is right for your application.
| Specification |
CL17 |
CLF10 sc / CLT10 sc |
| Accuracy |
± 5% or 0.03 mg/L, whichever is greater |
CLF10 sc = ±3% at pH<7.2 (±0.2 pH unit), ±10% at a pH<8.5 (±0.5 pH unit) CLT10 sc = ±10% at a pH<8.5 (±0.5 pH unit) |
| Minimum Detection Limit (MDL) |
30 ppb |
30 ppb (or less) |
| Response Time |
Batch analysis, 150 seconds cycle time |
Continuous, CLF10 sc T90 = 140s CLT10 sc T90 = 100s |
| Regulatory Method |
SM 4500 CLG 40CFR 141.74 EPA Method 334.0 |
EPA Method 334.0 |
| Measurement Technology |
DPD Colorimetric Method |
Amperometric Method |
| Automated Cleaning Available |
No |
Yes |
4. Keys to application success
| Factor |
CL17 |
CLF10 sc / CLT10 sc |
| Appropriate Applications (Requirements) |
- Must be able to replace reagents monthly
- Must have a system to manage the waste stream (if required)
|
- Must have uninterrupted sample flow
- Must have uninterrupted power
- Sample pH should be stable within +/- 0.5 pH unit from the average value
- Chlorine concentration should be within +/- 20% from the average value
|
Questions? Be sure to consult your local sales representative for an application audit and to match the best solution for your application.